Solving MySQL Error 1336: Ordering Variable and Condition Declarations Correctly

by

Understanding the Error

MySQL Error 1336, SQLSTATE 42000 (ER_SP_VARCOND_AFTER_CURSHNDLR), occurs when a variable or condition declaration is placed after a cursor or handler declaration within a stored routine. In MySQL, there is a specific order that must be followed when declaring components of a stored procedure or function. Variables and conditions must be declared before cursors and handlers.

Diagnosing the Issue

To diagnose this error, look at the order of declarations in your stored procedure or function. Check if any variables or conditions are declared after cursors or handlers. Here’s an example that would cause Error 1336:

DELIMITER $$

CREATE PROCEDURE MyProcedure()
BEGIN
    DECLARE myCursor CURSOR FOR SELECT column1 FROM myTable;
    DECLARE myVariable INT; -- Variable declared after cursor declaration
    DECLARE CONTINUE HANDLER FOR NOT FOUND SET done = TRUE;

    -- Procedure logic
END$$

DELIMITER ;

In this example, myVariable is declared after the cursor myCursor, which is against the rules for declaration order in MySQL.

Solutions to Fix Error 1336

Reordering Declarations

To fix this error, ensure all variable and condition declarations are placed before any cursor or handler declarations. Here’s the corrected version of the previous example:

DELIMITER $$

CREATE PROCEDURE MyProcedure()
BEGIN
    DECLARE myVariable INT; -- Variable declared before cursor and handler
    DECLARE done INT DEFAULT FALSE;
    DECLARE myCursor CURSOR FOR SELECT column1 FROM myTable;
    DECLARE CONTINUE HANDLER FOR NOT FOUND SET done = TRUE;

    -- Procedure logic
END$$

DELIMITER ;

Structuring Stored Procedure

A good practice is to structure your stored procedure with declarations in the following order:

  1. Variables
  2. Conditions
  3. Cursors
  4. Handlers

This structure ensures that you won’t encounter Error 1336. Here is a template for the correct order:

DELIMITER $$

CREATE PROCEDURE MyProcedure()
BEGIN
    -- Variable declarations
    DECLARE myVariable INT;
    DECLARE anotherVariable VARCHAR(255);

    -- Condition declarations
    DECLARE done INT DEFAULT FALSE;

    -- Cursor declarations
    DECLARE myCursor CURSOR FOR SELECT column1, column2 FROM myTable;

    -- Handler declarations
    DECLARE CONTINUE HANDLER FOR NOT FOUND SET done = TRUE;

    -- Procedure logic
END$$

DELIMITER ;

Reviewing and Testing Changes

After reordering the declarations, review your stored procedure or function to ensure that the logic still makes sense with the new order. Test the routine to confirm that it executes without error and behaves as expected.

Conclusion

MySQL Error 1336 is a reminder of the importance of following the correct order of declarations in stored procedures and functions. Always declare variables and conditions before cursors and handlers. By structuring your routines with this order in mind, you can avoid this error and create well-organized and error-free stored routines.

Leave a Comment