Navigating MySQL Error 1089: Fixing Incorrect Sub Part Key Issues

by

MySQL Error 1089, denoted by SQLSTATE code HY000 (ER_WRONG_SUB_KEY), occurs when there’s an issue with the creation of an index that involves a sub part key. The error message “Incorrect sub part key; the used key part isn’t a string, the used length is longer than the key part, or the storage engine doesn’t support unique sub keys” points to a few potential problems with how the sub part of the key is specified. This guide will help you diagnose the underlying cause of this error and provide you with solutions to fix it.

Understanding the Error

Sub part key indexing is used to index a prefix of a column, which is common with large string data types like VARCHAR or CHAR. Error 1089 is triggered if the prefix length is incorrectly specified, if the column data type isn’t suitable for sub part indexing, or if the storage engine doesn’t support this feature.

Diagnosing the Issue

To resolve the error, you need to check the index definition in your SQL statement. Ensure that the column you are indexing is a string data type and that the specified length of the sub part key does not exceed the length of the actual column. Also, verify that the storage engine you are using supports sub part keys.

Fixing the Error

Scenario 1: Specifying Correct Sub Part Length

When creating an index with a sub part, ensure the length specified does not exceed the column’s actual length:

-- Incorrect index creation with sub part length longer than the column length
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column VARCHAR(10),
  INDEX (my_column(20))
);

-- Corrected index creation with appropriate sub part length
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column VARCHAR(10),
  INDEX (my_column(10))
);

Scenario 2: Using Sub Part Indexing with String Types

Sub part keys are only valid for string data types, such as CHAR, VARCHAR, BINARY, and VARBINARY:

-- Incorrect index creation using a sub part on an INT column
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column INT,
  INDEX (my_column(4))
);

-- Corrected index creation without a sub part on an INT column
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column INT,
  INDEX (my_column)
);

Scenario 3: Choosing the Right Storage Engine

Some storage engines, like MyISAM, support sub part keys, while others may not. Ensure your table uses a compatible storage engine:

-- Specifying the storage engine that supports sub part keys
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column VARCHAR(255),
  INDEX (my_column(10))
) ENGINE=MyISAM;

Scenario 4: Correcting Unique Sub Part Keys

If you’re creating a unique index with a sub part, ensure that the sub part is sufficient to maintain uniqueness:

-- Attempting to create a unique index with a sub part that may not be unique
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column VARCHAR(255),
  UNIQUE INDEX (my_column(5))
);

-- Corrected unique index creation with a longer sub part
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column VARCHAR(255),
  UNIQUE INDEX (my_column(50))
);

Scenario 5: Avoiding Sub Part on FULLTEXT Indexes

FULLTEXT indexes do not support sub part keys, so ensure you’re not using them together:

-- Incorrect FULLTEXT index creation with a sub part
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column TEXT,
  FULLTEXT (my_column(100))
);

-- Corrected FULLTEXT index creation without a sub part
CREATE TABLE my_table (
  my_column TEXT,
  FULLTEXT (my_column)
);

Conclusion

Error 1089 in MySQL typically indicates a mistake in the use of sub part key indexing. By ensuring that sub part lengths are within the column’s actual length, using sub part indexing with the correct data types, selecting a storage engine that supports this feature, and avoiding sub part keys in certain index types like FULLTEXT, you can resolve this error. It’s important to carefully plan your indexing strategy and understand the capabilities of your database’s storage engine to prevent such errors. Always backup your database before making structural changes to safeguard against data loss.

Leave a Comment